The college's intercollegiate athletic teams, the Tigers and Lady Tigers, compete in the Southern States Athletic Conference (SSAC) in Division I of the National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics (NAIA).[6] The college currently fields four varsity athletic teams, including: men's and women's basketball, baseball, and softball. Beginning in Fall 2018, the college will be adding Men's and Women's Cross Country and Track and Field.

Recent Athletic accomplishments include:

Men's Basketball - In 2018 the Men's Basketball Team was the NAIA A.I.I Conference Champs. Losing in the opening round of the National Tournament, the men finished the season with a record o 27–5, losing only one game at home. The Tigers swept the conference awards with the Coach of the Year, Defensive Player of the Year, Newcomer of the Year, and a 1st Team Honorable mention. 2006 and 2016 SIAC Championship;[7] In the 2009–10 season, 1 year removed from taking over a 1–27 team, head coach Michael Grant led the men's basketball team to the school's first ever appearance in the National Top 25 rankings.

Women's Basketball - In 2018, the Lady Tigers were the NAIA A.I.I. Conference Champ Runner Ups. The Lady Tigers lost in the opening round of the National Tournament and finished with a 19–12 record.

Baseball - In 2018, the Tigers finished their season with a record of 19–22; 2007–2008 SIAC Championships; 2007 Division II National Championship

Softball - The 2018 Lady Tigers Softball team finished with a record of 18-18, an impressive record considering the installation of a new coach in December and a 0–8 start to the season.